NYE Dress Debate

New Year's Eve can be one of those hit or miss occasions. It generally gets very hyped up and something ends up going wrong. This year, A and I have the same goal- spend it together and don't worry about anything else. We've already booked ourselves a hotel in Columbus and made dinner reservations at a fancy restaurant in town. I'm sure we will have friends out and about or even hosting parties in their homes but we will figure all that business out later.

What I am worried about at the moment... which dress do I wear? I ordered two options from ModCloth and here they are (disclaimer.... I am NOT a fashion blogger, I'm not used to this picture taking business):

[one]

The Giving Legend Dress- This dress is classy and the little flared skirt at the bottom makes it different than any other dress in my closet. The fit is not bad- I might have actually been alright in a small on this one- but it have room in it to be comfortable when I've got that fancy dinner and wine in my belly. Ideally I would like to style this with matte black tights and electric blue heels to play off the blue in the dress.

[two]

The Ruby Blooms Dress- This dress does not leave much to the imagination. It is slinky, and sexy in red. I love the big keyhole detail in the back. I do not have a red dress in my closet yet, which was one of the reasons I purchased it. I think the would make a great holiday party/New Year's dress, maybe even Valentine's day too. But I feel like it's options for repeated wear might be a bit more limited that the dress above (unless I'm planning a trip to Vegas anytime soon). I think I would pair this one with black tights and black heels as I have in the picture.

So what do you guys think... which one should I wear for NYE?